Law 

Legal News [October 2026]: Supreme Court examines a co-owner’s right to information

October’s selection of Supreme Court case law offers important findings on the law of obligations, co-ownership, state liability for excessively lengthy proceedings, and corporate law. The Supreme Court emphasized the need to establish the terms of a contractual relationship properly before assessing a claim for unjust enrichment, defined the scope of a manager’s duty to provide information to the co-owners of jointly owned property, and clarified the conditions for awarding monetary compensation for delays in proceedings concerning the provision of information. It also examined the duty of loyalty of board members and whether it is consistent with the duty of due managerial care for them to arrange, through their own companies and for a fee, the performance of activities that fall within their responsibilities as board members.

In its judgment of 11 August 2026, case no. 27 Cdo 719/2025, the Supreme Court considered whether a claim for restitution of unjust enrichment can be upheld without the court first properly establishing the terms of the contractual relationship under which performance was provided.

The claimants sought repayment of funds provided to the defendant in connection with a planned investment and the acquisition of shares. The lower courts upheld their claim, finding that the defendant had been unjustly enriched at their expense. However, the Supreme Court concluded that the court must first establish the actual substance and purpose of the legal act under Sections 555 and 556 of the Civil Code, and only then assess whether a claim for unjust enrichment exists. A valid contract generally precludes unjust enrichment, since it provides a legal basis for performance. As the courts had proceeded on the assumption that contractual relationships existed without properly assessing their terms, their conclusion on unjust enrichment was premature. The Supreme Court therefore quashed the decisions of both lower courts and remitted the case for further proceedings.


In its judgment of 25 August 2026, case no. 22 Cdo 2406/2025, the Supreme Court examined the scope of a manager’s duty to provide information to a co-owner of jointly owned property where management is carried out by a third party under Section 1135 of the Civil Code.

The claimant, a co-owner of real estate, sought information and supporting documents concerning the management and operation of the jointly owned property from the company entrusted with managing the premises. The lower courts dismissed most of his claim, reasoning that a co-owner’s right to information cannot be equated with a right to receive every individual document relating to management, and that the claimant had already been granted the right to an account of the management. However, the Supreme Court emphasised that the manager of jointly owned property has the status of a mandatary, and the manager’s duty to provide information therefore cannot be assessed solely under the rules governing co-ownership. The manager must provide information and accounts to an extent that enables co-owners to oversee the management, while the specific scope of the supporting documents requested must be assessed individually in light of the circumstances of the case. As the appellate court had not considered the manager’s status under Section 1135 of the Civil Code, the Supreme Court quashed its decision and remitted the case for further proceedings.


In its judgment of 31 August 2026, case no. 30 Cdo 1765/2026, the Supreme Court considered whether the negligible importance of proceedings concerning the provision of information under Act No. 106/1999 Coll. automatically precludes an award of monetary compensation for their excessive length.

The claimant sought an apology and compensation for non-pecuniary harm of CZK 150,000 for proceedings concerning a request for information addressed to the Police of the Czech Republic and the Ministry of the Interior, which had lasted almost four years. Although the appellate court acknowledged the excessive length of the proceedings, it did not award monetary compensation, reasoning that the information requested was not of fundamental importance to the claimant. The Supreme Court emphasised that the importance of the proceedings to the injured party is a key criterion when assessing the form of compensation, but it cannot be considered in isolation. Monetary compensation may be appropriate even in proceedings of low or negligible importance, particularly where serious errors by public authorities contributed substantially to their excessive length, such as the repeated quashing of flawed decisions, prolonged inactivity, or so-called administrative “ping-pong”.

The Supreme Court also reiterated that compensation under Act No. 82/1998 Coll. primarily serves to compensate for harm and provide redress, rather than to penalise the state. It criticised the appellate court for failing to address adequately the alleged errors of the administrative authorities and their impact on the severity of the harm suffered by the claimant. It therefore quashed the part of the decision concerning monetary compensation and remitted the case for further proceedings.


In its judgment of 31 August 2026, case no. 27 Cdo 3331/2025, the Supreme Court considered whether board members exercise due managerial care when they delegate, for a fee, activities falling within the board’s remit to companies they control and then effectively perform those activities themselves.

The claimant, HC Sparta Praha a. s., sought damages exceeding CZK 32 million from former board members. It alleged that the defendants had breached their duty of due managerial care by providing intermediary and advisory services to the claimant through companies they controlled, thereby effectively performing activities within the board’s remit for a fee (remuneration and commissions paid to the controlled companies). The lower courts dismissed the claim, reasoning that the agreed services had been provided on customary terms, had brought the company an economic benefit, and had caused it no loss.

However, the Supreme Court emphasised that due managerial care cannot be assessed solely on the basis of the outcome or economic benefit of the conduct in question. Whether the board members acted loyally and in the company’s justifiable interests is also decisive. Where board members arrange, for a fee, for activities within their remit to be performed through their own companies and subsequently perform those activities themselves, such conduct may conflict with their duty of loyalty to the company. According to the Supreme Court, it is therefore necessary to establish who actually performed the activities in question and whether the defendants had merely impermissibly “hired themselves” to carry out activities they should have performed as part of their roles. It is also necessary to assess whether there was a reasonable justification, defensible from the company’s perspective, for involving their companies, based on the circumstances known at the time of the decision rather than on the subsequent economic outcome.

Legal News

Upcoming events

Seminars, webcasts, business breakfasts and other events organized by Deloitte.

    Show morearrow-right